ADP TotalSource is where a lot of companies start their PEO journey. It's a big brand, the onboarding is relatively smooth, and for companies under 50 employees, it can make sense. But at some point, the math changes. Admin fees climb. Your medical renewal comes in hot, and you have no leverage because you're on their master plan. You want to customize your benefits, pick your own HRIS, or simply stop paying a middleman to do things your team can handle.
If you're at that point, here's what you need to know. We've helped companies exit ADP TotalSource dozens of times. The transition is predictable, manageable, and almost always results in significant savings. But it requires coordination and at least 90 days of lead time.
If someone tells you they can get you out of ADP TotalSource in under 90 days, be skeptical. Rushed exits create sloppy, painful experiences for your HR team and, more importantly, for your employees. Benefits gaps, payroll errors, missed enrollments. We take the time to do it right.
Before You Start: Review Your Contract
ADP TotalSource contracts typically have a notice period and a defined contract term. Before you do anything else, pull your agreement and look for three things: your contract end date, the required notice period (usually 30 to 60 days), and any early termination fees or penalties. Most companies time their exit to coincide with their benefit plan renewal, which avoids mid-year disruption to employee coverage and sidesteps potential FICA/FUTA tax restart issues.
Even if your renewal is months away, starting the analysis early gives you maximum leverage. The more time you have, the better your market options and the smoother the transition.
The 6-Step Process for Leaving ADP TotalSource
Get Your Invoices Analyzed
The first step is understanding what you're actually paying. We request your current ADP TotalSource invoices broken down by employee, your employee census data (demographics, dependents, coverage tiers), plan SBCs, and your renewal date. From there, we run a complete cost analysis that breaks out admin fees, medical premiums, ancillary costs, and workers' comp into individual line items so you can see exactly where your money goes.
This typically takes about two weeks from the time we receive your documents.
Run a Full Market Comparison
Once we know what you're paying, we go to market on every single line. Medical benefits are quoted across UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, BCBS, Kaiser, and regional carriers. We model fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded options. Because ADP TotalSource doesn't share claims data, we use census-based actuarial modeling to identify the funding strategy that saves you the most.
Dental, vision, life, STD/LTD, and all ancillary lines are individually marketed to competing carriers. Workers' comp is unbundled and quoted separately. EPLI coverage is sourced standalone.
Select Your HRIS and Payroll Platform
Leaving ADP TotalSource means leaving their Workforce Now-based platform. This is actually one of the biggest upgrades most companies experience. We work with trusted HRIS partners who interview your team to understand your current workflows and match you with the right system. Our clients get preferred pricing and dedicated senior implementation specialists, not a junior rep managing 50 accounts at once.
Common platforms companies move to include Paylocity, ADP Workforce Now (standalone, without the PEO), Paychex Flex, UKG, and Paycom.
Finalize Benefits and Carriers
Based on the market results, you select your plans and carriers. We handle all carrier negotiations, plan design, and setup. We build carrier feeds with your new HRIS so enrollment and eligibility flow seamlessly. Your employees see better options, clearer communication, and a modern enrollment experience.
Coordinate the Transition
This is where having an experienced team matters. We coordinate the timing between ADP TotalSource's offboarding, your new HRIS implementation, carrier effective dates, and payroll cutover. Open enrollment is handled. Employee communications are prepared. There is no gap in coverage, no gap in payroll, and no confusion for your employees.
We also ensure workers' comp, EPLI, and state tax registrations are all in place before the effective date.
Go Live and Beyond
On the effective date, your employees are on their new plans, your payroll runs through your new platform, and you're officially out of the PEO. But the relationship doesn't end there. We manage your renewals, run annual market checks, handle open enrollment, and serve as your ongoing benefits advisor. Leaving a PEO is step one. Building a multi-year strategy to maximize your benefits spend is the real goal.
How Long Does the Full Transition Take?
These phases overlap, which is how the whole process fits within 90 days. Starting earlier gives you more breathing room, which means better outcomes for everyone involved.
Thinking About Leaving ADP TotalSource?
We've done this dozens of times. Send us your invoices and census data, and we'll show you exactly what you'd save. Free, no obligation.
Get Your Free AnalysisWhat Do Companies Typically Save?
Our clients leaving ADP TotalSource typically save $90,000 to $100,000+ per year. The savings come from eliminating admin fees, getting competitive medical rates on the open market, unbundling workers' comp, and individually marketing every ancillary line. For companies with 100+ employees, savings regularly exceed $150,000 annually.
These aren't theoretical numbers. They're based on real analyses we've run for real companies.
What About My Employees?
This is the question every HR director asks, and it's the right one. Done properly, your employees experience zero disruption. Coverage transitions seamlessly, payroll continues without interruption, and the new HRIS platform is typically a significant upgrade from what they were using inside ADP TotalSource.
In most cases, employees end up with more plan options, lower deductibles, a modern self-service portal, and better overall benefits. The technology upgrade alone is something people notice immediately.
Why Work With LeavePEO?
We don't just help you leave. We handle everything: the analysis, the market comparison, the carrier negotiations, the HRIS selection, the implementation coordination, the employee enrollment, and the ongoing advisory. Every line of coverage, every vendor relationship, every compliance requirement. Start to finish and beyond.
We're backed by IMA Financial Group, the 2nd largest independent brokerage in the country, with 3,000+ employees and nationwide carrier access. That means your 100-person company gets the same negotiating leverage as a Fortune 500.
The analysis is free. If the numbers say you should stay in ADP TotalSource, we'll tell you. But in our experience, they rarely do.
Ready to See the Numbers?
No cost. No pressure. Just an honest analysis of what ADP TotalSource is really costing you.
Get Your Free Analysis